Head To Head: Bonavita Coffee Maker vs. Technivorm

In the world of drip coffee machines, there are two names to remember. The question becomes, in a matchup between the Bonavita Coffee Maker vs. Technivorm, which one would come out on top? The answer is complex and ultimately depends on what, exactly, you’re looking for in terms of a top-tier drip coffee machine. We’ll unravel the mystery just below.

Technivorm Coffee Makers

Let’s start with the Technivorm Moccamaster.

For years, the Dutch wonder has been the best in class and the final word in drip-based machines. Its durable, rugged construction and simple design make it virtually indestructible.

When you buy one, you can rely on the fact that it will provide years of reliable, hassle-free service. This is borne out by the fact that the company offers a staggering five-year warranty, which is unheard of in the industry. European styling and European built means attractiveness and durability. Always has.

The downside though is the fact that you’ll pay a hefty premium for it. The machine retails at around three hundred dollars. For that price, you can actually buy a fairly good espresso machine. Not a super-automatic, by any means, but it a nice, serviceable one, for sure.

Bonavita Coffee Makers

On the flip side, there’s the American upstart, Bona​​​​vita.

 The Americans hired a team of German engineers to create a “Technivorm Killer,” and it shares some of the same, European stylings. In order to keep costs down, the company made the decision to have the machine manufactured in China, and that move did indeed succeed in allowing the company to offer their product at a significantly lower price than the Dutch wonder. Literally half the price. You can pick up a Bonavita for around $150, as of the time of this writing.

Variants of Bonavita Coffee Maker

A smaller image of Bonavita BV1901GW Glass Carafe
Glass Carafe
A smaller image of Bonavita BV1901GW Stainless Steel Carafe
Stainless Steel Carafe

Technivorm Coffee Maker vs Bonavita: Drawbacks

Cost vs Quality

The main drawbacks that Bonavita suffers from though, also stem from the decision to have the unit manufactured in China. The bottom line is that cheaper, lower-quality components were used, and it shows.

While the unit will cost you significantly less, it also won’t last as long, and this is borne out by the fact that Bonavita can only offer a two-year warranty on its product.

Many Technivorm owners have had their machines for ten years or more, and they’re still working as well today as they were on the day they were purchased!

Two conclusions right off the bat then, if you’re not willing to sacrifice on quality, then the Bonavita has nothing on the Technivorm, and the Dutch machine is the one you want. On the other hand, if you’re on a budget, and are looking for a great, world-class coffee maker without having to spend an arm and a leg, the Bonavita is your clear winner.

An image of technivorm coffee maker vs bonavita
Moccamaster KBG 741

The Brew (Taste and Process)

Now let’s talk about the heart and soul of the matter, the taste of the coffee both models produce, and the details of the brewing process. 

Here, the two machines are virtually identical. Both brew at about the same speed (a little over six minutes from start), and both use a brewing temperature that’s within just a couple of degrees of each other. Taste-wise, you can expect a consistently good cup of coffee from either machine and a high-quality brew. 

The Bonavita gets a slight nod here, in the way the shower head is arranged. It gives the grounds a better overall saturation, which could, in theory, lead to a slightly better brew.

The Technivorm has a counter for this, however. Where the Bonavita’s grounds compartment is enclosed, the Dutch machine’s is open, allowing you to stir the grounds as the water enters the chamber. If you don’t mind a bit of babysitting and a more hands-on approach to your coffee, this will actually provide a slightly better cup of coffee.

On the other hand, if you prefer the convenience of hands-and-hassle-free brewing, the Bonavita gets a slight edge here. Note, however, that the Bonavita’s design doesn’t lend itself to easy cleanup as the Technivorm does, so when it comes time to wash the various components to get them ready for next use, the Technivorm comes out on top.

Final Thoughts on Bonavita Coffee Makers vs Technivorm

There’s no doubt about it, you can’t go wrong with either machine, but also, it’s hard to name a clear-cut winner between the two.

In the contest between the Bonavita vs Technivorm Coffee Makers, what it really comes down to is personal taste and preference.

If you have the money to spend, the Technivorm is a great investment, because of its sheer durability. Pay the premium and use it for years.

If you’re on a budget and aren’t sure you’re willing to spend $300 on a top-tier drip-style machine, then the Bonavita will give you the flavor you’re looking for at a bargain price, while sacrificing the longevity of the machine.

Sources and Official Brand Websites

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *